Catherine Binet

Catherine Binet (Peruvian Forensic Anthropology Team – EPAF): Before going to university, Catherine interned at EDUCA, a Mexican NGO that promotes community development in the department of Oaxaca. Catherine completed her undergraduate studies in International Development and Hispanic Languages at McGill University, where she graduated with first class honours. At the time of her fellowship, she was studying for a Masters degree in International Development and Global Studies at the University of Ottawa. The Human Rights Internet in Ottawa supported Catherine’s fellowship.



Ciro Castillo and the Unrelenting Search for One Disappeared

04 Sep

In Peru, everyone knows the name of Ciro Castillo Rojo. The young man disappeared almost five months ago in the Colca Canyon, in the southern region of Arequipa. Literally every day since I have set foot in Peru, I have seen Ciro’s face (or his parents’ or his girlfriend’s) grace the frontpage of at least one local newspaper. In fact, catching up with the headlines about his case has become a ritual of sorts for me, as for countless others.

The saga of Ciro’s disappearance and the on-going search for him (or, at this point, his remains) has captivated the nation, and for good reason. The story has all the ingredients of a detective novel: a young couple goes trekking in the world’s deepest canyon, gets lost, and decide to part ways for unclear reasons. The girlfriend is eventually rescued a few days later, dehydrated but in otherwise good shape; the boyfriend is never seen or heard from again.

Daily accounts of the investigation, of the efforts of research and rescue teams—brought from as far as Mexico—of the frequent turnarounds in the case, and of the unflinching determination of Ciro´s parents to find their son, can be found in all media. Partly, this is due to a widely shared suspicion that there is more to the story than the rescued girlfriend is letting on, based on inaccuracies and changes in her story, her apparent lack of grief for the missing Ciro or sympathy for his famiy, and her perceived unwillingness the help the investigation.

La Republica frontpage

Being based at EPAF, it is hard to miss the obvious parallel between this one disappeared and the 15,000 Peruvians disappeared during the period of the internal armed conflict. Only, while the country gasps and awes at each new revelation, each turn of events in the Ciro case, the search for the 15,000 missing persons that EPAF works to locate and identify goes widely unnoticed.

“Ciro’s parents will never be at peace until he is found”—I read a few days ago at a newsstand. This is true. But equally true is that the parents, siblings, spouses, and children of Peru’s 15,000 disappeared are not at peace either. In the majority of cases, they have not been at peace for more than 20 years. Where are the headline stories about them? Could it be that the fact that they have been suffering for so long makes their suffering less important, less relevant?

A recent street poll conducted for EPAF’s new WebTV show Duro de Roer clearly demonstrated that people in Lima know very little, if anything, about the issue of the disappeared in their country. Asked how many of them there might be, answers ranged from “Ciro Castillo” to “120” to “1 million”.  I like to think that if people were more aware and informed on the issue, popular support for such measures as a national plan for the search and identification of missing persons, the need for which EPAF has iterated and reiterated ad nauseum, would soar.

In my view—and I am fully aware that my position as an outsider makes it only too easy for me to critique—Peruvian civil society has not yet managed to coalesce around the issue with the level of coherence and effectiveness required. And the mainstream media, a potentially crucial ally, has certainly not been as supportive of the issue as it could be. At at time when human rights organizations are finding it more and more difficult to secure funding, the challenges they face are as great as ever…

Posted By Catherine Binet

Posted Sep 4th, 2011

5 Comments

  • Tania

    September 16, 2011

     

    Kate,
    It is just an observation.
    Peru and its civil, social, and otherwise organizations are Peru’s and Peruvians’ business only. We do not need human rights organizations (HRO) in our nation. You may not have said it. But you seem to imply that HROs are necessary and that they need funding. You should know that most of us Peruvians are tired of HROs, since they have advocated terrorist groups and individuals. Thus, the Ciro case and the other thousands of dissapeared people is of our business. We do not want HROs to corrupt our nation. We have our problems, we will deal with them… We are not Iraq or Afganistan…

  • Catherine Binet

    September 17, 2011

     

    Dear Tania, thank you for your comment. The organization I work with, EPAF, is 100% Peruvian. You seem to imply that human rights organizations are an imposition from the outside, which they are not. Contrary to what you may think, most Peruvians do believe in the importance of protecting Peruvians´ human rights, and this is why there are so many Peruvian human rights organizations.

  • Amelia

    October 2, 2011

     

    Tania

    I am Peruvian, and I believe HRO are needed in Peru, either from Peru or from outside Peru. Unfortunately, Peru is a corrupted country and missed people, those thousend mentioned by Karen, most likely will never appear. We do nothing to find them, we did nothing for them, we even did not know when and how were missed/killed/disappeared/etc. People react different in a case of individual dissapearance or massive one. If it is massive people say nothing. If it is one, they at least talk about it. HRO told us how many Peruvians were lost/killed, otherwise we would think nothing ever hapened. I know Ciro’s case is just one of thousands unfortunated cases.
    Tania, we should learn from others to fight our problems. We have nearly 190 years of independence solving our own problems. Nothing have been solved. We are still undeveloped and poor while at the same time other countries are in better position. So, I do not share your nationalist point of wiew.

  • Dara

    November 12, 2011

     

    That is some thing I must find more information directly into, thanks for the publish.

  • Cedric

    November 17, 2011

     

    It is really an outstanding write-up. Posts similar to this tend to be unusual on the web. I know, because I read a great deal of content on the internet. You have led important, intriquing, notable and well crafted info on this issue.

Enter your Comment

Submit

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

 

 

Fellows

2019
2018
2017
2016
2015
2014
2013
2012
2011
2010
2009
2008
2007
2006
2005
2004
2003